Medtech Insight is part of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC’s registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use. For high-quality copies or electronic reprints for distribution to colleagues or customers, please call +44 (0) 20 3377 3183

Printed By


Consumers Union files brief against federal pre-emption in Medtronic case

This article was originally published in The Gray Sheet

Executive Summary

The publisher of Consumer Reports files an amicus curiae brief Aug. 27 with the Supreme Court in favor of the Riegel family, which sued Medtronic for defective design, among other things, after an Evergreen balloon catheter burst inside Charles Riegel's artery during an angioplasty procedure in 1996. A district court decision that Medtronic is protected against state suits by federal pre-emption was upheld on appeal in November 2006 (1"The Gray Sheet" July 2, 2007, p. 3). Device firms have successfully used federal pre-emption in several other cases tried in lower courts. But Consumer Reports says the purpose of the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act is to protect consumers. "The Court should be exceptionally chary of an interpretation of the statute that would use a new regulatory layer (like the Medical Device Amendments) to sweep away an old one (state based remedies of the common law)," the group says in its brief...

You may also be interested in...

Supreme Court To Judge Protective Power Of PMA Approval In State Suits

The U.S. Supreme Court on June 25 agreed to consider whether device manufacturers are protected by FDA premarket approval in state product liability cases

Jefferies' Survey Predicts M&A Rebound In 2021

An upturn in M&A activity across the whole healthcare sector is expected in 2021, with the COVID-19 pandemic and the associated development of a vaccine shining a light on the sector, says a recent survey by Jefferies. 

Clinuvel’s Phototoxicity Drug Scenesse Approved In Third Market

Australian patients with phototoxicity due to the rare condition EPP will now have their first treatment option – provided the drug's developer, Clinuvel, secures reimbursement under the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme.




Ask The Analyst

Ask the Analyst is free for subscribers.  Submit your question and one of our analysts will be in touch.

Your question has been successfully sent to the email address below and we will get back as soon as possible. my@email.address.

All fields are required.

Please make sure all fields are completed.

Please make sure you have filled out all fields

Please make sure you have filled out all fields

Please enter a valid e-mail address

Please enter a valid Phone Number

Ask your question to our analysts